Even in Genesis, a book known for the intense drama of its action – from the creation of the world to the discovery of sex, from the flooding of the world to the multiplication of human languages – the Torah portion of Vayeira (‘And [God] Appeared’) is a doozy.
We get the destruction of the sinful cities of Sodom and Gomorrah, brimstone and fire raining down upon them, our first Matriarch conceiving a child at the age of 90, and our first Patriarch sending his first born son to die in the desert and then nearly sacrificing his second on a mountaintop.
At the centre of much of the action is that second son of Abraham, the baby born midway through the portion, who will become our second Patriarch, Isaac. Isaac is in many ways the passive Patriarch, a characteristic we see in both of the tales about him in this portion. First, presumably as a young child, his older half-brother Ishmael plays with him in a way that his mother Sarah finds offensive or upsetting, leading to her demand that Abraham banish both Ishmael and his mother, the Egyptian slave Hagar.
Secondly, as the youth or young man who goes along with his father to be sacrificed like a lamb, to be saved only at the very last minute by an intervention from an angel.
Ahead in his future, Isaac will have his wife Rebekah chosen by his father’s servant, and while Rebekah will be asked if she wants the marriage, there is no sign anyone asks Isaac if he does.
And finally, blind and believing he is near the end of his life, Isaac will be tricked by that wife, Rebekah, into blessing her favourite son, Jacob, rather than Isaac’s best-loved, Esau.
Given the life that Isaac leads, it feels bitter that his name means ‘He will laugh’.
As we seek to understand why Isaac, who never seems to have cause for laughter during the tales we know about him, has such an ironic name, it is worth looking at the three times laughter appears in Vayeira.
The name derives from his mother Sarah’s response to overhearing God tell Abraham that Sarah will conceive and bear a child, though ‘the way of women’ had ceased for her – at 90, she is post-menopause – and her husband Abraham is 100 years old.
Not surprisingly, hearing this notion from God, Sarah laughs. The text specifies that this laughter is ‘within herself’, and the contemporary American Bible scholar Tammi J Schneider proposes that the laughter is with delight at the thought she might once again get sexual pleasure from her aged husband, but God seems slightly miffed at Sarah’s laughter.
God asks Abraham why his wife laughed – addressing the husband, not the wife, and asking a question the husband surely cannot answer, not least since, unlike God, Abraham presumably cannot hear his wife’s internal laughter. Fortunately for Abraham, Sarah intervenes, denying that she laughed, earning a rebuke from God and a promise that she will bear a son within a year.
Sarah’s laughter may be with joy, but God seems to interpret it as mocking or disbelief. Even if Schneider is right – and the text supports her interpretation, with Sarah asking herself if she will have ‘pleasure’ from her husband, in both the Everett Fox and the JPS translations of the Torah – laughing in the presence of God is a dangerous thing to do.
Variations on the Hebrew word for laughter appear two other times in the portion, and, as with Sarah’s laughter, both come with overtones of danger or threat.
One is when Ishmael ‘plays’ with Isaac, prompting his banishment. The Torah uses the same word for Ishmael’s playing that it does for Sarah’s laughing, and generations of rabbis have noted darkly that, while it is not clear exactly what Ishmael’s ‘play’ is, in this context the word could suggest sexual abuse. (These rabbis, of course, may have been seeking to make a villain of Ishmael in order to justify Sarah sending him out into the desert.)
The final case of the word ‘laugh’ comes from Lot’s sons-in-law when he warns his family they must flee Sodom before God destroys it. In the JPS translation, to his unnamed (and doomed) sons-in-law, Lot ‘seemed … as one who jests’. If we wanted to make obvious the repetition of the word for laughter in this portion, we might translate the response of Lot’s sons-in-law with that often pugnacious British challenge: ‘You having a laugh?’
Our modern society prizes laughter. We tell ourselves that ‘Laughter is the best medicine’.
Our ancestors also valued laughter, as is shown by our telling and retelling the Talmudic story of God trying to intervene in a debate between Rabbi Eliezer on the one side and all the other rabbis on another. In response to Rabbi Eliezer’s attempts to prove he is right by calling for miracles, God makes a carob tree jump out of the ground, water run backwards in an aqueduct, the walls of the study house buckle as if to collapse, and finally a voice come the heavens to declare that Eliezer is right. The rabbis won’t have it, and cite a verse from the Torah to demonstrate that it is now in their hands, not God’s, to interpret Jewish law.
What did God do when the rabbis made that declaration, a rabbi later asks the prophet Elijah.
God laughed, Elijah says, and added: ‘My children have defeated me!’
But this week’s Torah portion, parashat Vayeira, takes a darker view of laughter. Laughter can help heal a wounded soul or signal rueful resignation.
But laughter can also be cruel. Laughter can be derisive. Laughter can insult.
These days, the anonymity of the internet makes it easy to mock people we disagree with rather than engaging with their ideas. Too many politicians – even those in offices which once endowed their holders with world leadership – resort to laughing at people they dislike, using laughter as a mark of disrespect.
The life of Isaac – He who will laugh, but whose life contains so much pain – teaches us that we must consider carefully the effects of our laughter. We must laugh with our fellows, not at them. We must not use laughter to dismiss or belittle, but to lift each other up, to ease pains, to bring joy.
Richard Allen Greene, LBC rabbinical student
The views expressed in this D’var Torah do not necessarily reflect the position of Leo Baeck College.